A Better Thanksgiving Turkey Starts with Brining

Let's Talk Turkey: How to Brine Your Pasture-Raised Turkey

We're including a complimentary packet of brining mix with our Meadowdale Farm turkeys this Thanksgiving. Brining is one of my favorite ways to prepare poultry, and it doesn't need to be complicated. All you really need is a container large enough for your turkey, cold water, a little refrigerator space (or a good cooler), and some planning.

If you don't use your brining mix this Thanksgiving, save it! You can use it for a whole pasture-raised chicken another time.

Why Brine a Turkey?

Brining means soaking poultry in a mixture of water and salt, usually with some sugar, herbs, and spices added for flavor. The salt changes the structure of proteins in the meat, helping them retain moisture as they cook. It also seasons the meat beyond the surface.

Alton Brown has been explaining the science behind brining for years on Good Eats, and Martha Stewart has featured the technique in many of her Thanksgiving recipes. There's a good reason cooks keep coming back to it: brining can help produce a juicy, flavorful bird.

Our pasture-raised turkeys spend their days outdoors, moving around and foraging. They develop muscle through natural activity, which can give the meat a different texture and flavor from conventional supermarket poultry. Unlike many grocery store turkeys that have already been injected with salt solutions, our birds haven't been pre-brined.

Brining is especially helpful for the breast meat, which is naturally leaner than the thighs and legs and can dry out if overcooked.

How to Use Your Meadowdale Farm Brining Mix

Our turkeys generally weigh around 14 pounds, and each complimentary packet contains approximately two cups of Morton kosher salt, sugar, and spices blended together.

For a fully thawed turkey, here's how to get started:

  1. Use the entire packet. Combine your Meadowdale Farm brining mix with approximately 3 gallons of cold water. This is an estimated dilution based on our mixture, so the finished brine should not be treated as an exact copy of a tested recipe.

  2. Dissolve the mix. Stir until the salt and sugar have dissolved. You can warm a small amount of the water first if needed, but the finished brine must be completely chilled before adding the turkey.

  3. Submerge your turkey. Place the unwrapped turkey in a food-safe container and pour the cold brine over it. The entire bird should be covered, including the breast, legs, and wings. If it floats, use a clean, food-safe plate to help keep it submerged.

  4. Keep it cold. Cover the container and refrigerate at 40°F or below.

  5. Brine overnight. For a thawed turkey around 14 pounds, I'd start with approximately 8–12 hours using this dilution, rather than leaving it soaking for an entire day.

  6. Remove and dry. Take the turkey out of the brine, discard the liquid, and pat the bird thoroughly dry with paper towels before roasting.

There's no need to add more salt or sugar. We've already included those in your packet.

You can also replace some of the water with unsalted vegetable broth if you'd like. Alton Brown uses vegetable broth in his traditional turkey recipe, but personally, I think plain water works just fine. Our pasture-raised turkeys already have plenty of flavor.

My Favorite Thanksgiving Trick: Using a Cooler

Here's something I've been doing for years: I thaw my turkey directly in brining liquid in a large cooler. It saves valuable refrigerator space during Thanksgiving week.

Alton Brown actually has a recipe specifically for this technique, called brine-thawing. His method uses a specially formulated brine and takes approximately 48–60 hours for a frozen 14–16-pound turkey.

That's longer than I want most people leaving their turkey in our brining mix, particularly since our mixture contains Morton kosher salt, which is denser by volume than some other kosher salts.

For our customers, my recommendation is to thaw your turkey first and use the shorter overnight brine described above. If you're interested in thawing and brining together, follow a recipe specifically developed for that longer process rather than simply extending the time with our packet. A completely frozen turkey may need considerably more time to thaw than the 8–12 hours recommended for brining.

For anyone using a cooler, here are a few things I've learned:

Choose a good container. I use a large, hard-sided cooler with a lid, thoroughly washed and sanitized before use. You can also buy oversized zip-top turkey brining bags. Just be sure to place the bag inside another container in case it leaks. Nobody wants three gallons of brine on the garage floor.

Keep the turkey covered. The brining liquid should completely submerge the bird. If you're using a brining bag, remove excess air and secure it so the whole turkey stays in contact with the liquid.

Watch the temperature. Your brine needs to remain at 40°F or colder the entire time. I like to use cold water and add ice to keep everything chilly. Remember that loose ice dilutes the salt concentration as it melts, so count it as part of your total liquid. Sealed ice packs are another option.

Use a thermometer. I like having a digital thermometer for checking the water temperature. An instant-read thermometer works, but a waterproof temperature probe with a continuous display and alarm is even better for a cooler.

My recommended thermometer —that i just keep by the cooler.

Find a secure location. A cool corner of the garage often works well for keeping the cooler out of the kitchen, but only if the temperature inside the cooler stays safely below 40°F. The garage itself doesn't have to be refrigerator-cold, but the brine does.

And please make sure your cooler is in a bear-proof location! Bears, raccoons, pets, and other wildlife may be very interested in what's inside. A garage isn't necessarily bear-proof if animals can access it.

Set a reminder on your phone. I suggest checking the cooler every six hours. Check the water temperature, make sure the bird is still submerged, and add ice if needed. A six-hour reminder is helpful, but the temperature must remain safe between checks, too. That's why continuous monitoring with an alarm is worth considering.

If you can't reliably maintain the proper temperature in a cooler, use the refrigerator instead.

Can You Leave a Turkey in the Brine Too Long?

Absolutely, and this is one of the most common mistakes.

More time doesn't necessarily mean more moisture or better flavor. When poultry sits in a concentrated salt solution too long, the meat can become overly salty and develop an unpleasant, almost spongy texture.

For our approximately 14-pound birds, 8–12 hours is a reasonable starting point when using the estimated dilution above with an already thawed turkey. Don't automatically extend that to 24 or 48 hours.

Alton Brown's longer brine-thawing recipe works differently because the salt concentration and process are designed for extended soaking.

If your turkey finishes brining before you're ready to roast, remove it from the liquid and refrigerate it. Don't leave it sitting in the brine simply because Thanksgiving dinner is still a day away.

Should You Rinse Your Turkey After Brining?

You'll find different opinions on this, even among experienced cooks.

Alton Brown's classic turkey recipe calls for rinsing after brining to remove excess salt from the surface. Some traditional Martha Stewart recipes make the same recommendation.

However, the USDA advises against washing raw poultry because water can splash bacteria around the sink, countertops, and nearby dishes.

If you've used the proper amount of salt and haven't left your turkey soaking too long, you generally won't need to rinse it. Simply remove it from the brine, let the excess liquid drain away, and pat the bird thoroughly dry with paper towels.

If you follow a recipe that specifically calls for rinsing away excess surface salt, be careful to minimize splashing and thoroughly clean and sanitize the sink afterward.

Drying the skin is worth the extra few minutes. Excess moisture makes it harder to achieve that beautiful golden-brown finish when roasting.

A Few Things Not to Do

Most brining mistakes are easy to avoid once you know what to watch for.

  • Don't add extra salt to your Meadowdale Farm packet. We've already included it.

  • Don't leave your turkey soaking longer than the recommended time.

  • Don't put poultry into warm brine.

  • Don't let the brining liquid rise above 40°F.

  • Don't use trash bags or containers that aren't food-safe.

  • Don't leave part of the turkey sticking out of the brine.

  • Don't reuse brine that's been in contact with raw poultry.

  • Don't assume brining means you can't overcook your turkey.

And please don't forget the meat thermometer when roasting! The USDA recommends cooking turkey to an internal temperature of 165°F, measured in the thickest part of the breast, the innermost thigh, and the innermost wing without touching bone.

Let your turkey rest before carving, and taste it before adding additional salt. The brine has already done much of the seasoning.

What If You Save Your Brine Mix for Chicken?

You certainly can, but you won't need the entire packet for one chicken.

A whole pasture-raised chicken is much smaller than a Thanksgiving turkey, so use a chicken-specific brining recipe and measure out an appropriate portion of your spice mix. You'll also want a shorter brining time.

The remaining dry mix can be kept in an airtight container in a cool, dry pantry for another meal.

Whether you're preparing a holiday turkey or a Sunday roast chicken, the same principles apply: use the correct amount of salt, keep the bird covered in cold brine, and don't leave it soaking too long.

Watch & Learn: Turkey Brining

Alton Brown: The Really Final Turkey, with Gravy: RELOADED — His frozen-turkey brine-thaw method, designed for a longer soaking period.

Alton Brown: Good Eats Roast Thanksgiving Turkey — His classic overnight-brined turkey recipe.

Martha Stewart: How to Brine a Turkey — Another approach to traditional brining, including timing and preparation.